It is without any trepidation that I present my list of the Top 10 Singles of 2008. I feel very strongly about my list and I've worked very hard to prepare it for you all. I am open to any and all criticism my list might receive and I will do my very best to respond to those comments in a respectful way. Admittedly, I've had some trouble in the past when it comes to getting extremely defensive about my music tastes...yet this year I would like to try to accept disagreement without striking back. Honestly, if you disagree with my list, the best thing to do would be to generate your own list of songs from 2008. At the very least, you'll be standing up for your own opinion and, hopefully, I'll see some songs I've never heard of. Then I'll be exposed to new music and my tastes will diversify. Every year I hope that my list generates this sort of response and rarely do I get to see such a reaction. Hopefully this year will be different. Although my tastes tend to swing mainstream, hopefully there are a few songs that you've never heard of that you'll investigate. Happy reading.
Quick clarification: This list is restricted to songs that were released as singles between December 2007 and November 2008. Album tracks that weren't released as singles aren't eligible for this list, however I do have a special section at the end that recognizes outstanding songs that weren't singles.
Also, this intro was a bit dry. Things will get a bit sassier now.
Bleeding Love by Leona Lewis
Well, I suppose I'll include this song. It's only the number one song on my iTunes, and the Jason Nevins remix is in my iTunes top 10. I guess that means I enjoyed the song. I guess. Let me back up and explain my personal journey with this song--a voyage filled with wonder and amazement, much like my discovery of cheesy tots. I discovered Leona Lewis during what was a very boring winter break. I had come back early to school because I was a Residential Adviser and therefore killed a lot of time with YouTube. In all fairness, my obsession with YouTube isn't limited to winter break. This really isn't important to the story. Anyway, I discovered Leona and was obsessed (Thus ends the Hemingway-esque prose section of this list). I was pretty confident that she was going to be a superstar, but I didn't really advertise my obsession with her because there was a little bit of doubt. Also, a friend of mine was a real buzzkill because he made fun of Leona's vibrato and that made me ashamed to brag about her. Holla. Flash forward several months, and I learned that her debut album was finally going to be released. Her debut single, Bleeding Love, was released in the UK in October of 2007 and I was obsessed from the very first second I heard it. That obsession hasn't ceased in the subsequent fourteen months that I've been listening to the song.
This is the best song of 2008 for several reasons:
1. Almost everyone is sick of it now. Hence it was huge. If you saw this song as number one and rolled your eyes, this is why.
2. Leona is British. Britain breeds great pop. This song is great pop.
3. It helped pioneer the modern Pop/R&B ballad genre (Yes, I just made this up). Beyonce was an R&B artist who added pop to her sound with Irreplaceable and spawned a bunch of imitations (Tattoo, Hate that I Love You, etc.). Leona is a pop artist who added an R&B beat to her ballad. Genius. I know, Apologize did it first. However, this was a much more subtle civil union of sounds.
4. This is my list and I am "Grab a Cop's Gun" crazy about the song. CRAZY PUTTY!!!!
5. She wears them most bedazzled dress ever in the UK version of the music video. Amazing.
6. According to the United World Charts, it is the song of the millennium in terms of sales. Suck that, Apologize.
7. It very nearly made my Top 10 songs of 2007 when it was only released in the UK. However, I wasn't sure that it officially counted. It officially counts now.
Paper Planes by M.I.A.
There are two songs on this list that I feel like I discovered before any of my friends. Paper Planes is one of those songs. I remember reading Rolling Stone's Top 50 Albums of 2007, and the number one album was by an artist I had never heard of: M.I.A. In a sudden burst of spontaneous behavior, I downloaded the album to see what was so great about it. It was weird, edgy, cool, and definitely a departure for me musically. The standout track came at the end of the album. As soon as I heard those four gunshots, I was hooked. I listened to the song all the time and nobody really knew. Slowly but surely, people started talking about M.I.A. and Paper Planes. I had a resident that asked me if I had the song and I scoffed. I heard it at the senior gala, and only a small group of people danced to the song. It wasn't until Pineapple Express that people really started to notice the song.
The genius of this song is its message. Most people who "know" the song are actually clueless. One of my huge musical pet peeves is when people don't really understand what a song is about and proceed to reference the song in inappropriate contexts. That's why I hate weddings where "I Will Always Love You" is the first dance or Republican campaigns where "Born in the USA" is the theme song. WAKE UP, PEOPLE. Anyway, now that I have that nonsensical rant out of my system, let me get back to the point. M.I.A. had a disastrous experience trying to get into the United States with her Visa and she was inspired to record this song. In Paper Planes, M.I.A. takes the typical American's stereotypical view of immigrants and puts them in a first person perspective. Many Americans are (irrationally) threatened by immigrants because those people think that the immigrants will only bring violence to the country and take "our" jobs. Listen to the chorus again with that in mind. Clearly M.I.A. is mocking us and, sadly, she's pretty dead on.
Love is a Losing Game by Amy Winehouse
This song was Amy Winehouse's last great single before she disappeared from the music scene. Released in December of 2007, this song actually never saw the light of day in the United States. I think that's a shame, because it is definitely the most achingly beautiful ballad of the year. Say what you will about Winehouse's personal life, she is a brilliant songwriter and singer (when she wants to be). This song perfectly captures the essence of heartbreak and, in my opinion, is the best song from her Grammy winning debut album. It loses a little ground on this list (especially compared to Rehab on last year's list) because of it's lack of prominence but compensates for the most well written song on the list.
Finally, here's proof that when Amy is on her A-game that she is one of the best in the business: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVMTshWbtpo
Oh, and before I get sass for this choice, let me say something preemptive. I know I references this song as a 2007 single in last year's list. However, I did change the rules to include December 2007 singles, which is when this song was released. Suck it.
Hot 'n Cold by Katy Perry
Katy Perry burst onto the music scene with her bi-curious smash, I Kissed a Girl. The song spent seven weeks at #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart and was an international sensation. However, I feel like Hot n Cold is a better song for one reason. It's catchier. The concept of a fickle love interest may not be the most unique idea, but this song is literally the most infectious single of the year. I think it deserves respect for that. The basic chorus, a sequence of opposites, rings in your head for days after listening to this song. It is complicated? No. It pop supposed to be complicated? Definitely not. When I originally started writing this list, I predicted a Grammy nomination for Best New Artist for Katy, but that she would receive stiff competition from Leona Lewis. Well, the Recording Academy has spoken. They think that Lady Antebellum is a more deserving nominee than both Katy and Leona. I hope that Lady Antebellum (and next year's follow-up, Sir MasonDixonLine) does very well at the award ceremony. Or that she (I think it's a she) trips on the train of her dress and falls down in front of everyone. One or the other.
More Like Her by Miranda Lambert
Miranda Lambert released the single best country cd I've ever heard. Her sophomore album, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, painted the perfect picture of an artist. Throughout the disc she threatens her ex, laments a dry town, and stands up for women. Listening to this album, you really get the sense that each song is from the perspective of the same angry, bruised woman. The album's most vulnerable moment is More Like Her, a sad ballad where Miranda blames herself for a breakup. I don't know why I'm so ballad crazy this year (or at least more-so compared to previous years), but slow jams definitely had a strong showing in 2008. Also, I could just be a sucker for ballads.
If I Were a Boy/Single Ladies by Beyoncé
So, I know I'm cheating a bit here. I'm counting both of these songs in one spot for a few reasons. First, I honestly couldn't decide which Beyonce song I liked better this year. Second, they were both released as the same time. Granted, this clearly doesn't make them the same single...but when it comes to my twisted list-making logic I feel the simultaneous release of these singles allows me to declare a tie. Finally, they were both great songs, so they definitely both deserve to make this list.
On another note, congrats to Beyonce for being the only artist to make my Top 10 songs list every year I've published a list.
If I Were a Boy really surprised me. Reading reviews for I am...SASHA FIERCE, I saw that most critics were torn on which disc was more of a risk for the Beyonce. Was it I Am, with its simple ballads and restrained singing, or SASHA FIERCE, with its adventurous new dance sounds? Personally, I feel like I Am is the bigger departure for Beyonce and that's part of the reason that I like If I Were a Boy so much. It's so simple in the writing and the melody, yet it effectively conveys the singer's heartbreak. I also love how the story of the song develops slowly and the real message of the song appears in the second verse: "If I were a Boy/I would turn off my phone/Tell everyone it's broken/so they'd think that I was sleeping alone." In that verse, the song's point is crystal clear. Tear.
Single Ladies is just a lot of fun. I'm not quite sure if this song would make the list without it's super fabulous music video (and every live performance where Beyonce does the choreography from the video), but that's sort of irrelevant at this point. The bottom line is that when this comes on at a club, everyone goes crazy and tries to imitate the dance moves. Hand flipping, hip thrusting, and butt slapping all show up. It doesn't hurt that the song is pretty great also. I know that this analysis might make it seem like I prefer If I Were a Boy, but honestly both songs are amazing and I truly can't pick one because they're so different and great. Good work, Beyonce. I suppose this means your album concept was a success.
No Air by Jordin Sparks, featuring Chris Brown
I love Jordin Sparks. Currently, she is my favorite American Idol winner (this might be different if David Cook's debut weren't disappointing and Kelly Clarkson had bounced back from My December). I really wanted to include Tattoo on my list last year, but I thought that choosing a song with the line "you're on my heart just like a tattoo" would destroy my credibility. Well, let's ignore the fact that Tattoo has more than 100 plays on iTunes. This year is my chance to include Jordin without feeling like a loser. In the debate between No Air and One Step at a Time, the choice is clear. No Air is an epic ballad and includes a performance from the incredibly popular Chris Brown. One Step at a Time, albeit a good song, doesn't have the same power as No Air. Furthermore, the best routine on So You Think You Can Dance this season was choreographed to No Air, which really emphasized the emotion in this song. Brilliant work. I can't wait to see what Jordin whips up in 2009.
On another note, I'm not going to punish a song for being ubiquitous. If you hate a song on this list because it was played to death, make your own list.
See You Again by Miley Cyrus
Let's be real. Miley's second album, Breakout, is way better than her previous work. However, See You Again, is still the definitive Miley single. As much as I like Breakout, 7 Things, and Fly on the Wall...I can't escape See You Again. So many Thursday afternoons were spent singing along to this song at WU and perhaps one of my most meaningful friendships at WU was strengthened by this song. Additionally, I still remember when a girl offered to show Richard her boobs if he would play See You Again a second time. Holla Senior Gala. What a classy night. Anyway, I've still got my sights set on this single and I think I'll be listening to it until I see you again, Josh.
Love Story by Taylor Swift
Lord this song is cute. Love Story equates a blossoming romance to Romeo and Juliet, which is probably the most well known love story of all time (except for KFed and Britney or William Taft and food). It's a pretty bold comparison, but the song is good enough to support this notion. Also, this song has the best key change on this list, and I'm a sucker for a good key change. Finally, I want to make sure Taylor Swift gets proper credit for the great work she did on her album Fearless. It's one of the best works of the year and it's full of catchy, well-written songs. One review of Fearless said Swift is a "song writing savant" and I tend to agree with that statement. Although she doesn't have the strongest voice in the business and she's pretty miserable as a live performer, she knows how to craft a song that suits her voice and strongly appeals to her fans. Good work, Tswift.
Womanizer by Britney Spears
Britney has had quite the career. Most people are familiar with her rise to fame and subsequent downfall. Furthermore, most people know this is Britney's second attempt at a comeback. Although Blackout was a perfectly good Britney album, she derailed all of her momentum with her disastrous VMAs performance. Well, Brit is giving fame another chance with her sixth studio album, Circus. Although the album is dramatically different from Blackout, the most noticeable difference is that Spears actually seems to be trying this time around. She's giving interviews, being "candid", and doing a decent effort to promote Circus without seeming like a human train wreck. Even her live performances (even though she still dances listlessly) seem to be improving steadily. Her case is strengthened by Womanizer, the outstanding lead single from the album. Although the song has the lyrical depth of her last lead single, Gimme More ("Gimme gimme more gimme more gimme gimme more..." vs. "Womanizer woman-womanizer you're a womanizer..."), it still is extremely catchy and well constructed. Here's to hoping that Britney finally gets the comeback she deserves.
Special Awards:
Most Disappointing: David Cook (Light On)
Looking at all of the previous Idol winners, if I had to anoint one as the Idol with the most potential (before their debut album was released), I would have picked David Cook. He did some of the most amazing arrangements Idol has ever seen and he has an incredible voice. I was so excited for his debut album because I expected him to deliver very catchy rock/pop. However, my excitement immediately disappeared upon hearing Light On. This song is so ordinary I can't stand it. David can do better. Now, his album isn't terrible--far from it. However, when I think about the potential he has as an artist, I really think he's failing to live up to that.
Artist of the Year: Rihanna
Ok, so I need to give credit where it's due. Rihanna had an incredibly successful year in 2008 with the release of several hit singles: Don't Stop the Music, Take a Bow, If I Never See Your Face Again (collaboration), Disturbia, Live Your Life (another collaboration), and Rehab. Although none of those songs cracked my top 10 list, I can't deny her phenomenal performance. Ryan Tedder called her the next Britney, and I think that could be true. Let's just hope she doesn't pull all of the crazy shit that Brit did. Runners-up: Lil' Wayne, Leona Lewis, and Chris Brown.
Should be Singles
Every year I feebly attempt to suggest songs that I think would fare well on the radio. Generally, my suggestions have ignored. Last year, only Break the Ice and Last Name were released after I suggested them. Sadly, Break the Ice didn't fair very well because Britney was a living shit show at that time. Last Name, however, faired very well on the country charts and received the second loudest scream at the Carrie Underwood concert I attended (after Before He Cheats). This year, I will attempt to cast a wider net and see if my suggestions hold true through 2009.
Take a Bow/Run-Leona Lewis. Sadly, some faux-hawked harlot released a grating ballad by the name of Take a Bow this summer. It basically took the generally theme of Leona Lewis' Take a Bow and made it more unpleasant to listen to. Just to clarify, Leona released her version of Take a Bow first--in the UK on her album Spirit. Anyway, I think Leona should still release the song in the United States, because it is damn catchy and would be a hit. Leona is currently releasing Run in the UK, but she has I Will Be slated as her next US single. Although I Will Be is a fine choice, Run is a much more emotional song. Hopefully she'll release Run stateside as well.
You Belong With Me-Taylor Swift. Ms. Swift is blessed with several single options on her sophomore album. I think this one is the strongest choice, but she has enough to choose from that I doubt she'll misstep.
Breakin' Dishes-Rihanna. RIRI IT'S NOT TOO LATE!!! PLEASE RELEASE BREAKIN' DISHES!!
One of the Boys-Katy Perry. I read somewhere that this might be her next single, but it's a very weak rumor. In any case, I think this is a good choice so I hope she follows through with it.
Paparazzi/Eh Eh-Lady Gaga. Ms. Gaga is finally getting the attention she deserves in the US. These two songs are my favorites, so I hope at least one of them gets some radio airplay. Eh Eh is my personal favorite, but I think Paparazzi has more potential.
Bad Influence-P!nk.
Breakout-Miley Cyrus.
Serious-Duffy.
American Idol of the Year
Jordin Sparks. Two years in a row, little J. Maybe KC will take this award next year. Here's hoping she bounces back.
Best Music Video
Single Ladies, Beyonce
Worst Music Video
Forgive Me, Leona Lewis. Mariah Carey must have taught her how to make music videos.
Guiltiest Pleasure
T-Shirt, by Shontelle
Lyric of the year
All of the boys and all of the girls are begging to if you seek Amy.
And on one final note, here are some songs that would have made my lists (had I been writing them) in previous years. I really wish I had started writing my Top 10 Songs list earlier on in my life, so here are some "retrospective anniversary" lists to satisfy my quarter-life crisis. They're in no particular order. Some of them were released prior to the year in which they were popular (noted in parenthesis), but since they were so huge, I counted them.
5th Anniversary
Beautiful, Christina Aguilera (Dec. 2002)
Crazy in Love, Beyonce
Hey Ya! Outkast
Miss Independent, Kelly Clarkson
Cry Me a River, JT (Dec. 2002)
Guilty Pleasure: Ignition/Stacy's Mom
10th Anniversary
...Baby One More Time, Britney Spears
Torn, Natalie Imbruglia
All My Life, KC & JoJo
The Boy is Mine, Brandy & Monica
My Heart Will Go On, Celine Dion
Off the Wall Choice: Bachelorette
Dreamlover, Mariah Carey
What's Up, 4 Non Blondes
That's the Way Love Goes, Janet Jackson
Can't Help Falling In Love, Ub40
I Will Always Love You, Whitney Houston (Oct 1992, but #1 for Jan and Feb of 1993). Awesomely bad song that I love: Whoomp! There it is.
20th Anniversary
Sweet Child O' Mine, Guns & Roses
Pour Some Sugar On Me, Def Leopard
Man in the Mirror (GREAT KEY CHANGE), Michael Jackson
Every Rose Has Its Thorn, Poison
Could've Been, Tiffany
Most YouTubed Song of 1988: Never Gonna Give You Up.